Thesis
Constitutional adjudication in the age of climate change: navigating complexity with humility
- Abstract:
-
This thesis explores the complex role of constitutional law and adjudication in addressing the multifaceted challenges posed by climate change. By examining the doctrinal debates and judicial reasoning in constitutional courts across various jurisdictions, it highlights how climate change—characterized by its polycentricity, temporality, spatiality, and multivalence—complicates traditional constitutional doctrines, including standing, justiciability, remedies, and rights adjudication.
Through a comparative analysis of over 30 constitutional judgments from around 20 jurisdictions, this thesis identifies judicial innovations and challenges in interpreting doctrines in constitutional climate disputes. The legal nature of climate change, it is argued, render climate disputes extraordinarily complex, disrupting familiar doctrines such as standing, causation, remedies, and the separation of powers, across jurisdictions. By confronting courts with long timelines, geographically diffuse harms, and multi-tiered governance structures, climate change compels them to reframe or evolve foundational constitutional principles.
Central to the thesis is the proposal of humility—epistemic, doctrinal, and institutional—as a guiding principle for courts, enabling them to adapt existing doctrines without overextending their institutional role. Epistemic humility encourages an acknowledgment of the limits of judicial knowledge, fostering openness to scientific uncertainty and evolving evidence. Doctrinal humility invites courts to adapt existing frameworks to the novel realities of climate change, while institutional humility underscores the need to balance judicial intervention with respect for the role of the political branches in constitutional governance.
The thesis critiques the narratives of courts as unequivocal champions of climate action, offering a more nuanced perspective on their contributions and constraints. It highlights judicial strategies, such as distinguishing between goals and means of climate action, and emphasizes the need for context-sensitive adjudication that respects constitutional diversity while addressing global challenges. By examining core doctrinal dilemmas—such as the extraterritorial effects of emissions, state duties to protect against future harms, and the allocation of authority in federal systems—this thesis reveals how climate change fosters a legal transition in which courts balance established values with evolving norms. Ultimately, the research advances constitutional scholarship by proposing a principled approach to adjudication, equipping courts to navigate the unprecedented complexities of climate change while upholding constitutional integrity and fostering long-lasting climate governance.
Actions
Access Document
- Files:
-
-
(Preview, Dissemination version, pdf, 2.6MB, Terms of use)
-
Authors
Contributors
+ Fisher, E
- Institution:
- University of Oxford
- Division:
- SSD
- Department:
- Law
- Role:
- Supervisor
- ORCID:
- 0000-0002-6955-8788
- DOI:
- Type of award:
- DPhil
- Level of award:
- Doctoral
- Awarding institution:
- University of Oxford
- Language:
-
English
- Keywords:
- Subjects:
- Deposit date:
-
2025-09-05
- ARK identifier:
Terms of use
- Copyright holder:
- Marcelo Lozada Gomez
- Copyright date:
- 2025
If you are the owner of this record, you can report an update to it here: Report update to this record