Thesis icon

Thesis

The invisible border wall: the use of artificial intelligence in Canada’s immigration and border control

Alternative title:
The Invisible Border Wall
Abstract:
In this thesis, I present my invisible border wall conceptual framework. I argue that the Canadian government has built this invisible wall to maintain its image as an immigrantfriendly nation; at the same time, this wall serves as a way to externalise the Canadian border, pre-sort migrants, and limit transparency. The wall has three ‘layers’ of ‘bricks’, each of which serves a distinct function. The foundational layer is built with migration, border externalisation, and outsourcing practices. The second layer of bricks is made of data collection, processing, and sharing practices. Algorithmic systems make up the third and newest layer of the invisible wall. Altogether, this wall pushes Canadian border control further away from its territorial lines and into data infrastructures, algorithms, contractors, and foreign governments.

A substantial portion of this thesis is dedicated to transparency, accountability, and fairness, which serve as the foundational principles and the ‘mortar’ of the invisible wall. These principles are intended to hold border control practices to account, legally and ethically. Yet, upon closer examination, the third layer of bricks is deepening the existing ‘cracks’ and ‘structural weaknesses’ in these foundations. When algorithmic tools are implemented without adequate understanding and oversight, these principles erode, undermining the conditions for just border management practices. Although the Canadian government has adopted algorithmic systems to speed processing, I show that these systems often produce externalities and new forms of remote control instead.

This wall and its processes exist as part of a larger ecology that is shaped by New Public Management thinking and historical inequities, where efficiency and cost-cutting imperatives take precedence, and procedural injustice persists. Canada is not unique in constructing such a wall; similar architectures of algorithmic border governance are emerging across liberal democratic states, such as the United Kingdom, Australia, the United States, and the European Union.

My theoretical contribution in this thesis is the concept of the invisible border wall, a framework for understanding how algorithmic technologies compound existing weaknesses in transparency, accountability, and fairness to entrench discriminatory border control practices, with implications for other high discretion, highly politicised domains of state power.

Actions

Authors

More by this author
Institution:
University of Oxford
Division:
SSD
Department:
International Development
Role:
Author

Contributors

Institution:
University of Oxford
Division:
SSD
Department:
International Development
Role:
Supervisor
ORCID:
0000-0003-3337-6437
Institution:
University of Oxford
Division:
SSD
Department:
Oxford Internet Institute
Role:
Supervisor
ORCID:
0000-0003-4597-8283


DOI:
Type of award:
DPhil
Level of award:
Doctoral
Awarding institution:
University of Oxford

Terms of use


Views and Downloads

Views and downloads will return soon






If you are the owner of this record, you can report an update to it here: Report update to this record

TO TOP