Thesis icon

Thesis

Constituting the nation: language and nationalism in the Indian Constitution and constitutional identity

Abstract:
Linguistic federalism and multilingualism in India’s official language provisions have been considered markers of pluralism in Indian constitutional identity and salutary for its democratic resilience. Yet both these constitutional choices emerged not from a founding consensus but through the process of strategic deferral and nationalist contestation. This thesis uses the analytical lens of nationalism to examine how competing ideas of Indianness shaped the language provisions in the Indian Constitution. It then analyses how subsequent constitutional developments regarding the official language and linguistic reorganisation of states shaped nation-building and constitutional identity. The thesis draws on interdisciplinary insights and conceptualises the relationship between nationalism and constitutions as the quest for congruence between national and constitutional identity.

It demonstrates that nationalist contestations resulted in the foregrounding of identitarian/symbolic considerations and essentialist conceptions of Indianness over pragmatic and functional considerations in framing the language provisions. It argues that the constitutional provisions, when combined with the linguistic reorganisation of states, created path dependencies and spaces for political mobilisation and the renegotiation of constitutional identity. These contestations enabled by constitutional design strategies such as deferral were a crucial factor in the emergence of a plural account of Indian constitutional identity, marking a departure from the distinctively unitary trajectory of nation-building based on a common language.

The thesis advances a conceptual and terminological framework for studying language in constitutional design. By analysing language corpus (script and vocabulary) as a distinct conceptual category, it contributes to the literature on Indian constitutional design. Moving away from the dominant civic-ethnic paradigm in Indian constitutional studies, it offers alternative frameworks for analysing nationalism’s influence on the Indian Constitution by identifying a typology of nation-building and dimensions of constitutional identity. The findings illuminate the contingent nature of India's linguistic pluralism and offer insights for understanding contemporary contestations over constitutional identity.

Actions

Authors

More by this author
Institution:
University of Oxford
Division:
SSD
Department:
Law
Role:
Author

Contributors

Institution:
University of Oxford
Division:
SSD
Department:
Law
Role:
Supervisor
Institution:
University of Oxford
Division:
SSD
Department:
Law
Role:
Supervisor
ORCID:
0000-0002-2125-4072


DOI:
Type of award:
DPhil
Level of award:
Doctoral
Awarding institution:
University of Oxford

Terms of use


Views and Downloads

Views and downloads will return soon






If you are the owner of this record, you can report an update to it here: Report update to this record

TO TOP