Thesis
Navigating customary and state governance: livelihoods and resilience in Aceh’s Social Forestry programme
- Abstract:
-
This thesis examines how customary institutions interact with Indonesia’s Social Forestry (SF) programme, a state-led form of community-based forest management (CBFM), to shape forest governance, livelihood benefits, and livelihood resilience. SF grants forest-dependent communities rights to manage or, once recognised as “Customary Law Communities,” own forests. Yet, outcomes remain uneven across communities in under-explained ways. The thesis draws on legal pluralism, institutional fit, the Theory of Access, and the Sustainable Livelihoods Approach, using a sequential mixed-methods design across four Aceh case studies, to ask: under what conditions, and through what institutional and livelihood mechanisms, does the interaction between Indonesia’s SF programme and customary institutions enable rural communities to develop locally grounded forest governance arrangements, realise livelihood benefits, and strengthen livelihood resilience?
The findings show that communities’ capacity to negotiate locally adapted governance arrangements depends on the strength of customary institutions and social cohesion, not on legal recognition alone; that formal management rights do not by themselves improve livelihoods, with benefit realisation instead shaped by how statutory requirements interact with customary institutions and communities’ ability to mobilise access to finance, labour, knowledge, technology, and authority; and that livelihood resilience depends less on income than on the mobilisation and convertibility of livelihood capitals, with customary norms functioning as a meta-institution structuring reciprocity, access, and collective support. Taken together, the thesis challenges the assumption that stronger community tenure rights necessarily translate into greater benefits, arguing instead that CBFM operates as an institutionally mediated, socially differentiated process of negotiating rights, realising benefits, and responding to shocks. It contributes an integrated account of how customary institutions shape CBFM’s differentiated outcomes, and suggests that policy in Indonesia and comparable settings should move beyond legal formalisation towards sustained support for locally legitimate institutions and context-sensitive resource access.
Actions
Authors
Contributors
+ McDermott, C
- Institution:
- University of Oxford
- Division:
- SSD
- Department:
- SOGE
- Sub department:
- Environmental Change Institute
- Role:
- Supervisor
- ORCID:
- 0000-0002-5238-0936
+ McDermott, C
- Institution:
- University of Oxford
- Division:
- SSD
- Department:
- SOGE
- Sub department:
- Environmental Change Institute
- Role:
- Supervisor
- ORCID:
- 0000-0002-5238-0936
Indonesia Endowment Fund for Education (Lembaga Pengelola Dana Pendidikan, LPDP)
More from this funder
- DOI:
- Type of award:
- DPhil
- Level of award:
- Doctoral
- Awarding institution:
- University of Oxford
- Language:
-
English
- Keywords:
- Subjects:
- Deposit date:
-
2026-11-16
- ARK identifier:
Terms of use
- Copyright holder:
- Pisca Ayuning Tias
- Copyright date:
- 2026
- Notes:
- Navigating the nexus between customary norms and state laws in shaping rural forest governance: a case study in Aceh Province, Indonesia is derived from this thesis.
If you are the owner of this record, you can report an update to it here: Report update to this record