Thesis icon

Thesis

Perceptual decision-making under uncertainty in humans

Abstract:

On a daily basis, humans need to make decisions in a complex uncertain world that requires them to adapt their decision strategies to the environmental volatility. In order to make a decision, humans often need to integrate noisy information and combine it with prior experience they learned through previous similar decision situations. This thesis examines how humans form decisions based on noisy information using electroencephalography (EEG), and how they make use of prior expectation in order to guide their decisions using magnetoencephalography (MEG). For both parts, models that capture the different decision-making processes were used to make predictions of human behaviour and underlying neural activity.

To study how humans integrate noisy evidence a novel continuous random dot motion task was developed in which signal periods had to be detected in a stream of noisy evidence which, in contrast to previous studies, is controlled by the experimenter. Simulations with a leaky accumulator model predicted that participants should discount past evidence to solve the task. Participant behaviour suggests that they adapted their evidence strategy to the frequency and length of signal periods in the noise in a manner that is consistent with leaky accumulation. A contingent negative variation (CNV) signal measured with EEG suggests that the brain adapted its evidence accumulation process in line with the behavioural results. In addition, a P300-like signal encoded the difference between previous and current evidence sample, scaling with the size of the difference and trial frequency.

To study how humans update their prior belief about decision outcomes a different random dot motion task was used in which participants had to integrate evidence within trials but also had to integrate prior expectation over past trial outcomes to inform choice. A Bayesian model was fit to subjects’ behavioural data to estimate the prior expectation on each trial that was subsequently used to study human choice behaviour and neural activity in the task. Human choice behaviour depended on both, the within-trial evidence, as well as prior belief. Activity in parietal cortex, measured with MEG, at the time of feedback suggested that the feedback type, i.e., whether a choice was correct or incorrect, is encoded in parietal cortex. There was only a very weak influence of prior belief on the neural signal.

Actions

Access Document

Files:

Authors

More by this author
Division:
MSD
Department:
Clinical Neurosciences
Role:
Author

Contributors

Institution:
University of Oxford
Division:
MSD
Department:
Psychiatry
Role:
Supervisor
ORCID:
0000-0002-8393-8533
Institution:
University of Oxford
Division:
MSD
Department:
Experimental Psychology
Role:
Supervisor
Institution:
University of Oxford
Division:
MSD
Department:
Experimental Psychology
Role:
Supervisor


Wellcome Trust More from this funder
Grant:
109064/Z/15/Z
Programme:
Wellcome Trust Doctoral Programme in Neuroscience


DOI:
Type of award:
DPhil
Level of award:
Doctoral
Awarding institution:
University of Oxford


Language:
English
Keywords:
Subjects:
Pubs id:
2042980
Local pid:
pubs:2042980
Deposit date:
2021-11-09
ARK identifier:

Terms of use


Views and Downloads

Views and downloads will return soon






If you are the owner of this record, you can report an update to it here: Report update to this record

TO TOP