No single measure is enough: recovery of the critically endangered Mobula mobular requires integrated maximum bycatch mitigation and nursery area protection

Preprint

As anthropogenic threats have intensified over the past 500 years, we find ourselves in the midst of a sixth mass extinction, with continued losses of biodiversity threatening ecosystem stability. This biodiversity loss has caused species extinctions across taxa, and placed several others at high risk of functional extinction. These disturbance-driven impacts represent one of the most acute biodiversity crises facing global marine systems. Species exhibiting slow life histories characteristically have low resilience to disturbance. Here, we assess the risk of functional extinction and identify policy pathways for population recovery of the slow-living, Critically Endangered elasmobranch, the spinetail devil ray (Mobula mobular). We develop a stochastic, state-structured Integral Projection Model (IPM) parameterised with demographic data collected from fishery landings data in India, the world’s largest mobulid fishery, and supplemented with data on vital rates from published literature. Using the IPM, we estimate that the population is declining at approximately 12% annually, experiencing substantial limiting pressure from fisheries overexploitation and failing to approach its biological maximum growth potential. Our results indicate that populations of M. mobular will be at high risk of functional extinction if ‘business as usual’ harvest scenario persists for another decade. We further show that long-term population recovery is only possible if survival increases significantly across all size classes, especially among large reproductive females, alongside a concurrent increase in fecundity. We conclude that no single policy measure is sufficient to recover population of M. mobular along the southeastern coast of India. Instead, combined protection through maximum bycatch mitigation and protection of nursery areas in no-take zones will be required for population recovery. This research demonstrates that recovery of overexploited populations often requires integrated resource management across life stages, and that the Critically Endangered M. mobular warrants urgent conservation action to avoid functional extinction.

Authors: Chopra, M; Salguero-Gómez, R; Stevens, GMW; Rowlands, G; Karnad, D

• Publication status: Published
• Preprint server: bioRxiv
• Publication date: 2026-08-19
• Acceptance date: 2026-08-19
• DOI: 10.64898/2026.08.18.744841
• Server owner: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
• Language: English
• Keywords: conservation policy; demography; elasmobranch; fisheries management; functional extinction; integral projection model; population recovery; spinetail devil ray