Is she a woman? Alternative critical frameworks for understanding cross-dressing and cross-gender casting on the Victorian stage

Journal article

As the study of nineteenth-century theatre has expanded over the decades, the extent and popularity of cross-dressing and cross-gender casting on the Victorian stage is being revealed. Yet there is an enduring tendency in Victorian theatre criticism to situate transvestite performances within broad-brush assumptions of binary attitudes towards gender amongst theatre audiences. Universalised gender norms and assumptions of binary thinking have long been discarded in critical analysis of Victorian fiction, and their lingering influence on Victorian theatre studies has arguably been unhelpful. Building on the vital pioneering work of Jacky Bratton, this article will focus on the careers of Louisa Cranstoun Nisbett and Mary Anne Keeley, two prominent and acclaimed mid-century actresses, drawing on reviews, memoirs, and commentaries on their performances to attempt to construct alternative theories for how they were viewed and understood. The critical and popular success of their performances and the language and ideas employed by reviewers and commentators to record and explain them reveal far more flexible, multiple, fluid, complex, and imaginative attitudes to gender roles and identities than allowed for in established critical narratives.

• Publication status: Published
• Peer review status: Peer reviewed
• Publisher: SAGE Publications
• Journal: Nineteenth Century Theatre and Film
• Volume: 50
• Issue: 1
• Pages: 3-20
• Publication date: 2023-01-18
• Acceptance date: 2022-12-15
• DOI: 10.1177/17483727221148852
• EISSN: 2048-2906
• ISSN: 1748-3727
• Language: English
• Keywords: drag; Mary Keeley; FFR; cross-dressing; cross-gender casting; Louisa Nisbett