Journal article icon

Journal article

Agentive modals

Abstract:
This essay proposes a new theory of agentive modals: ability modals and their duals, compulsion modals. After criticizing existing approaches—the existential quantificational analysis, the universal quantificational analysis, and the conditional analysis—it presents a new account that builds on both the existential and conditional analyses. On this account, the act conditional analysis, a sentence like ‘John can swim across the river’ says that there is some practically available action (in a sense the essay makes precise) that is such that if John tries to do it, he swims across the river. The essay argues that the act conditional analysis avoids the problems faced by existing accounts of agentive modality and shows how the act conditional analysis can be extended to an account of generic agentive modal claims. The upshot is a new vantage point on the role of agentive modal ascriptions in practical discourse: ability ascriptions serve as a kind of hypothetical guarantee, and compulsion ascriptions as a kind of nonhypothetical guarantee.
Publication status:
Published
Peer review status:
Peer reviewed

Actions

Access Document

Files:
Publisher copy:
10.1215/00318108-3878483

Authors

More by this author
Institution:
University of Oxford
Division:
HUMS
Department:
Philosophy Faculty
Role:
Author


Publisher:
Duke University Press
Journal:
Philosophical Review More from this journal
Volume:
126
Issue:
3
Pages:
301-343
Publication date:
2017-07-01
Acceptance date:
2016-10-18
DOI:
EISSN:
1558-1470
ISSN:
0031-8108


Language:
English
Keywords:
Pubs id:
pubs:1043493
UUID:
uuid:aef2ddf9-fc04-46b1-900a-e29ab1921328
Local pid:
pubs:1043493
Source identifiers:
1043493
Deposit date:
2019-08-14
ARK identifier:

Terms of use


Views and Downloads

Views and downloads will return soon






If you are the owner of this record, you can report an update to it here: Report update to this record

TO TOP