Journal article icon

Journal article

COVID-19 differentiated measures for unvaccinated individuals: The need for clear goals and strong justifications

Abstract:
Numerous countries and jurisdictions have implemented differential COVID-19 public health restrictions based on individual vaccination status to mitigate the public health risks posed by unvaccinated individuals. Although it is scientifically and ethically justifiable to introduce such vaccination-based differentiated measures as a risk-based approach to resume high-risk activities in an ongoing pandemic, their justification is weakened by lack of clarity on their intended goals and the specific risks or potential harms they intend to mitigate. Furthermore, the criteria for the removal of differentiated measures may not be clear, which raises the possibility of shifting goalposts without clear justification and with potential for unfairly discriminatory consequences. This paper seeks to clarify the ethical justification of COVID-19 vaccination-based differentiated measures based on a public health risk-based approach, with focus on their deployment in domestic settings. We argue that such measures should be consistent with the principal goal of COVID-19 vaccination programmes, which is to reduce the incidence of severely ill patients and associated healthcare burdens so as to protect a health system. We provide some considerations for the removal of vaccination-based differentiated measures based on this goal.
Publication status:
Published
Peer review status:
Peer reviewed

Actions

Access Document

Files:
Publisher copy:
10.1016/j.vaccine.2022.06.051

Authors

More by this author
Institution:
University of Oxford
Division:
HUMS
Department:
Philosophy Faculty
Role:
Author


Wellcome Trust More from this funder
Grant:
203132/Z/16/Z
Grant:
203132/Z/16/Z


Publisher:
Elsevier
Journal:
Vaccine More from this journal
Volume:
40
Issue:
36
Pages:
5333-5337
Publication date:
2022-06-23
Acceptance date:
2022-06-19
DOI:
ISSN:
0264-410X


Language:
English
Keywords:
Pubs id:
1265884
Local pid:
pubs:1265884
Deposit date:
2022-06-28
ARK identifier:

Terms of use


Views and Downloads

Views and downloads will return soon






If you are the owner of this record, you can report an update to it here: Report update to this record

TO TOP