Journal article icon

Journal article

Mapping scientific agreement and disagreement: the case for a dedicated center

Abstract:
From 2022 to 2025, initial steps were taken toward establishing a dedicated center for systematically mapping scientific agreement and disagreement. This paper examines whether creating such a body is both desirable and feasible. We summarize lessons from three pilot studies (COVID-19; the existence of extraterrestrial life; claims of extraterrestrial life discovery), outlining key design choices. We then catalog and analyze prominent objections, drawing on perspectives from philosophy of science, social epistemology, STS, and political philosophy. We distinguish the proposed remit of such a center from Collins and Evans’s Owls: unlike the Owls it would be non-statutory, non-directive, and descriptive, providing auditable snapshots and longitudinal baselines of expert judgment rather than policy or governance prescriptions. Our conclusion is that, under appropriate design constraints, a center of this kind is operationally tractable and normatively defensible, and, if properly designed, can illuminate patterns of disagreement, uncertainty, and agreement without licensing technocracy or elitism.
Publication status:
Published
Peer review status:
Peer reviewed

Actions

Access Document

Files:
Publisher copy:
10.1162/posc.a.598

Authors

More by this author
Institution:
University of Oxford
Division:
SSD
Department:
Blavatnik School of Government
Role:
Author
ORCID:
0000-0002-6571-4325


Publisher:
Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press
Journal:
Perspectives on Science More from this journal
Pages:
1-87
Publication date:
2026-10-30
DOI:
EISSN:
1530-9274
ISSN:
1063-6145


Language:
English
Pubs id:
2491727
Local pid:
pubs:2491727
Source identifiers:
W7223919935
Deposit date:
2026-11-02
ARK identifier:

Terms of use


Views and Downloads

Views and downloads will return soon






If you are the owner of this record, you can report an update to it here: Report update to this record

TO TOP