Constituent power in socialist regimes

Journal article

The twenty-first century has witnessed the global resurgence of constituent power—the power to make a constitution—in both academic debate and the practice of constitutional adjudication and design. Comparative constitutional law scholarship on this power has largely focused on democratic settings. Little academic attention has been paid to the constiuent power in socialist regimes. To fill in this gap, this Article explores the design and practice of the constituent power in both former and current socialist regimes. It identifies three paradigms of the socialist constituent power. In the revolutionary paradigm, the power is used at the founding moment after a communist revolution to establish the legal foundation for a socialist state. In the Soviet, post-revolutionary paradigm, constitutent power is a power of the ordinary legislature used for the replacement of an existing by another socialist constitution. In the contemporary reformist paradigm, the socialist constituent power is still vested in an ordinary legislature but its design and practice integrate ideals and practices of democratic constituent power, including public engagement in constitutional reforms, as the consequence of the people’s struggle for their constituent power and the global diffusion of the idea of the popular constituent power. The reformist paradigm is illustrated by a case-study of Vietnam, using original resources. This study has implications for understanding the Soviet legacies and contemporary dynamics of constituent power in the socialist regimes, and for the comparative study of constituent power.

Authors: Bui, NS

• Publication status: Published
• Peer review status: Peer reviewed
• Publisher: Cambridge University Press
• Journal: German Law Journal
• Volume: 26
• Issue: 3
• Article number: 361-387
• Publication date: 2025-05-16
• Acceptance date: 2025-01-22
• DOI: 10.1017/glj.2025.20
• EISSN: 2071-8322
• Language: English
• Keywords: constituent power; Soviet; socialist regime; Vietnam