Consensus on Recommended Functions of a Smart Home System to Improve Self-Management Behaviors in People With Heart Failure: A Modified Delphi Approach

Journal article

BackgroundSmart home systems could enhance clinical and self-management of chronic heart failure by supporting health monitoring and remote support, but evidence to guide the design of smart home system functionalities is lacking.ObjectiveTo identify consensus-based recommendations for functions of a smart home system that could augment clinical and self-management for people living with chronic heart failure in the community.MethodsHealthcare professionals caring for people living with chronic heart failure participated in a two-round modified Delphi survey and a consensus workshop. Thirty survey items spanning eight chronic health failure categories were derived from international guidelines for the management of heart failure. In survey Round 1, participants rated the importance of all items using a 9-point Liket scale and suggested new functions to support people with chronic heart failure in their homes using a smart home system. The Likert scale scores ranged from 0 (not important) to 9 (very important) and scores were categorized into three groups: 1–3 = not important, 4–6 = important, and 7–9 = very important. Consensus agreement was defined a priori as ≥70% of respondents rating a score of ≥7 and ≤ 15% rating a score ≤ 3. In survey Round 2, panel members re-rated items where consensus was not reached, and rated the new items proposed in earlier round. Panel members were invited to an online consensus workshop to discuss items that had not reached consensus after Round 2 and agree on a set of recommendations for a smart home system.ResultsIn Round 1, 15 experts agreed 24/30 items were “very important”, and suggested six new items. In Round 2, experts agreed 2/6 original items and 6/6 new items were “very important”. During the consensus workshop, experts endorsed 2/4 remaining items. Finally, the expert panel recommended 34 items as “very important” for a smart home system including, healthy eating, body weight and fluid intake, physical activity and sedentary behavior, heart failure symptoms, tobacco cessation and alcohol reduction, medication adherence, physiological monitoring, interaction with healthcare professionals, and mental health among others.ConclusionA panel of healthcare professional experts recommended 34-item core functions in smart home systems designed to support people with chronic heart failure for self-management and clinical support. Results of this study will help researchers to co-design and protyping solutions with consumers and healthcare providers to achieve these core functions to improve self-management and clinical outcomes in people with chronic heart failure.

Authors: Islam, SMS; Nourse, R; Uddin, R; Rawstorn, JC; Maddison, R

• Publication status: Published
• Peer review status: Peer reviewed
• Publisher: Frontiers Media
• Journal: Frontiers in Cardiovascular Medicine
• Volume: 9
• Pages: 896249-896249
• Article number: 896249
• Publication date: 2022-06-29
• DOI: 10.3389/fcvm.2022.896249
• EISSN: 2297-055X
• ISSN: 2297-055X
• Language: English
• Keywords: Nominal group; Scale (ratio); Computer science; Rating scale; Psychology; Delphi; Likert scale; Heart failure; Medicine; Artificial intelligence; Gerontology; Delphi method