Influence of incorrect staging of colorectal carcinoma on oncological outcome: are we playing safely?

Journal article

Accurate preoperative staging of colorectal cancers is critical in selecting patients for neoadjuvant therapy prior to resection. Inaccurate staging, particularly understaging, may lead to involved resection margins and poor oncological outcomes. Our aim is to determine preoperative imaging accuracy of colorectal cancers compared to histopathology and define the effect of inaccurate staging on patient selection for neoadjuvant treatment(NT). Staging and treatment were determined for patients undergoing colorectal resections for adenocarcinomas in a single tertiary centre(2016-2020). Data were obtained for 948 patients. The staging was correct for both T and N stage in 19.68% of colon cancer patients. T stage was under-staged in 18.58%. At resection, 23 patients (3.36%) had involved pathological margins; only 7 of which had been predicted by pre-operative staging. However, the staging was correct for both T and N stage in 53.85% of rectal cancer patients. T stage was understaged in 26.89%. Thirteen patients had involved(R1)margins; T4 had been accurately predicted in all of these cases. There was a general trend in understaging both the tumor and lymphonodal involvement (T p < 0.00001 N p < 0.00001) causing a failure in administrating NT in 0.1% of patients with colon tumor, but not with rectal cancer. Preoperative radiological staging tended to understage both colonic and rectal cancers. In colonic tumours this may lead to a misled opportunity to treat with neoadjuvant therapy, resulting in involved margins at resection.

Authors: Reali, C; Bocca, G; Lindsey, I; Jones, O; Cunningham, C

• Publication status: Published
• Peer review status: Peer reviewed
• Publisher: Springer
• Journal: Updates in Surgery
• Volume: 74
• Issue: 2
• Pages: 591-597
• Publication date: 2021-07-06
• DOI: 10.1007/s13304-021-01095-3
• EISSN: 2038-3312
• ISSN: 2038-131X
• Language: English
• Keywords: Internal medicine; Medicine; Carcinoma; Surgery; Cancer; Outcome (game theory); General surgery; Colorectal cancer