Measures of relative metacognitive accuracy are confounded with task performance in tasks that permit guessing

Journal article

It has been debated whether children's metacognitive monitoring and control processes rely on a general resource or whether metacognitive processes are task specific. Moreover, findings about the extent to which metacognitive processes are related to first-order task performance are mixed. The current study aimed to uncover the relationships among children's monitoring (discrimination between correct and incorrect responses), control (accurate withdrawal of wrong answers), and performance across three memory-based learning tasks: Kanji learning, text comprehension, and secret code learning. All tasks consisted of a study phase, a test phase, monitoring (confidence judgments), and control (maintaining/withdrawing responses). Participants were 325 children (151 second graders [Mage = 8.12 years] and 174 fourth graders [Mage = 10.20 years]). Confirmatory factor analyses showed that a model in which monitoring and control loaded on a joint factor and performance on a separate factor provided the best fit to the data. Fourth graders had better monitoring and control accuracy than second graders. However, the factor structure of metacognition was similar for both age groups, contradictory to the assumption that metacognition generalizes across tasks as children grow older. After accounting for task-specific processes, monitoring and control skills for language-based memory tasks appear to be generalizable in middle childhood. In sum, children's monitoring and control for three separate memory tasks appear to reflect a unitary metacognition-for-memory factor related to, but distinguishable from, performance

Authors: Vuorre, M; Metcalfe, J

• Publication status: Published
• Peer review status: Peer reviewed
• Publisher: Springer
• Journal: Metacognition and Learning
• Volume: 17
• Issue: 2
• Pages: 269-291
• Publication date: 2021-01-11
• DOI: 10.1007/s11409-020-09257-1
• EISSN: 1556-1631
• ISSN: 1556-1623
• Language: English
• Keywords: Task (project management); Mathematics; Cognition; Response bias; Psychology; Artificial intelligence; Resolution (logic); Cognitive psychology; Artifact (error); Metacognition; Correlation; Social psychology; Computer science; Contrast (vision)