Existentialism and exemplars

Journal article

In this paper, Kate Kirkpatrick argues that the recent return to moral exemplars in exemplarist moral theory might benefit from engaging with existentialists' use of exemplars in two ways: first, by considering the role of negative exemplars and the power of emotions other than admiration in moral formation; and second, by considering objections to exemplarist education, in particular Simone de Beauvoir's objection that narrative exemplars often serve an ideological function and perpetuate oppressive ideals — especially (but not only) about women. After situating this discussion in ancient and recent debates about the role of literary narratives in moral formation, Kirkpatrick outlines a moral perfectionist reading of Beauvoir and an objection to exemplarist moral theory's reliance on exemplars that “we” admire on the basis that “the admirable” often serves to promote the interests of the powerful rather than the flourishing of all human beings. Finally, while agreeing with this symposium's editors that efforts to improve our understanding of how to use narrative exemplars in educational settings are valuable, she asks how, given the force of the Beauvoirian objection, their criterion of “appropriate critical reflection” might be met.

Authors: Kirkpatrick, K

• Publication status: Published
• Peer review status: Peer reviewed
• Publisher: Wiley
• Journal: Educational Theory
• Volume: 73
• Issue: 5
• Pages: 762-781
• Publication date: 2023-11-27
• Acceptance date: 2023-11-10
• DOI: 10.1111/edth.12600
• EISSN: 1741-5446
• ISSN: 0013-2004
• Language: English
• Keywords: ethical criticism; Simone de Beauvoir; moral perfectionism; exemplars; The Second Sex; Friedrich Nietzsche; Martha Nussbaum; existentialism