Strategy, Pyrrhonian scepticism and the allure of madness

Journal article

Justin Garson introduces the distinction between two views on Madness we encounter again and again throughout history: Madness as dysfunction, and Madness as strategy. On the latter view, Madness serves some purpose for the person experiencing it, even if it’s simultaneously harmful. The strategy view makes intelligible why Madness often holds a certain allure—even when it’s prima facie terrifying. Moreover, if Madness is a strategy in Garson’s metaphorical sense—if it serves a purpose—it makes sense to use consciously chosen strategies for living with Madness that don’t necessarily aim to annihilate or repress it as far as possible. In this paper, we use our own respective stories as case studies. We have both struggled to resist the allure of Madness, and both ended up embracing a kind of Pyrrhonian scepticism about reality instead of clinging to sane reality.

Authors: Jeppsson, S; Lodge, P

• Publication status: Published
• Peer review status: Peer reviewed
• Publisher: University of Rijeka
• Journal: European Journal of Analytic Philosophy
• Volume: 21
• Issue: 2
• Pages: 117-132
• Publication date: 2025-05-25
• Acceptance date: 2023-10-01
• DOI: 10.31820/ejap.21.2.2
• EISSN: 1849-0514
• ISSN: 1845-8475
• Language: English
• Keywords: madness; Pyrrhonian scepticism; mania; psychosis; psychiatry