Review of the target trial methodological approach on treatment effect estimates in kidney failure: protocol for a systematic assessment

Journal article

: Background: Patients with kidney failure often lack robust evidence because they are excluded from randomized trials. Trial emulation provides an alternative approach to derive treatment effect estimates when randomized trials cannot be conducted. Critical questions about the comparative efficacy and safety of interventions in kidney failure are now being answered using this approach or parts of it. However, variations and inconsistencies in reporting cast doubt on the reliability and validity of effect estimates not derived from randomized trials. The aim of this methodological systematic review is to understand the extent to which the target study approach is used in kidney failure and the appropriateness of this approach. By identifying and evaluating studies that qualify as emulating a target trial, compared with studies that did not apply the principles. We aim to provide more specific methodological guidance to increase the clarity and reliability of reporting treatment effect estimates when running a trial in kidney failure is not feasible. Methods: This protocol is developed in accordance with Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses Protocols (PRISMA-P) statement. MEDLINE, Embase, and reference lists (backwards citation chasing) will be searched up until 1st July 2023 and the search updated prior to publication to identify all studies evaluating patient outcomes in late-stage kidney disease and failure that use target trial emulation as the primary approach for analysis. Two authors (A. A., P. K.) will select articles based on title and abstract and then full text, with a third reviewer settling disagreements (J. P.). The prespecified variables will be extracted, and the risk of bias will be assessed by at least two authors (A. A., P. K., A. N.) using prespecified data forms. This will enable the determination of the robustness of the methodological quality of observational studies in using the whole or elements of the target trial approach. We will thereby assess their ability to reliably report treatment effect estimates. Discussion: We will provide specific methodological recommendations on how to design target trials and model assumptions for emulation to get reliable treatment effect estimates for therapeutic interventions in kidney failure. Methodological systematic review registration: Open Science Framework: Identifier https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/Z4Y29.

Authors: Pinter, J; Tunnicliffe, DJ; Karunikaikumar, P; Anastasiadis, A; Hills, RK

• Publication status: Published
• Peer review status: Peer reviewed
• Publisher: BioMed Central
• Journal: Systematic Reviews
• Volume: 13
• Issue: 1
• Article number: 280
• Publication date: 2024-11-14
• Acceptance date: 2024-09-29
• DOI: 10.1186/s13643-024-02672-4
• EISSN: 2046-4053
• ISSN: 2046-4053
• Language: English
• Keywords: Kidney failure; Target trial emulation; Methodological systematic review